Home › Forums › Current Special: XP Anniversary › Reviews of XP, Circa 2001
Here are some online copies of reviews from back in the day:
The one from PCWorld is actually a contemporary review for XP’s 25th anniversary.
Windows 8.1 is an odd beast. On the one hand it is like a service pack for Windows 8, and you could even upgrade it in-place through the Microsoft Store. On the other hand, Microsoft bumped the minor version number from 6.2 to 6.3, to make it look like a bigger change. No idea why someone would keep running the non-8.1 version, but maybe there are reasons. Some folks prefer XP SP2 to XP SP3. Apparently it works better on older systems.
Internal versioning of Windows never struck me as logical, and certainly not as disciplined as modern conventions like Semantic Versioning.
That said, it’s interesting how glowing some of the professional reviews turn out. I recall a lot of hate for XP being too cute and colorful. Folks called it Fischer-Price Windows. Looking back, I think XP was a great upgrade as machines grew powerful enough to take advantage. Its backward compatibility DB and subsystems (or were they proto-VMs?) were welcome, at least compared to Win NT and Win 2K.
If it still had security fixes, it could be a (relatively) light daily driver.
Microsoft changing the major version from 5 to 6 for Vista caused an unexpected number of application compatibility issues, so they were very cautious and stuck with major version 6 all the way through Win7, 8, 8.1 and even early drops of Win10 were 6.4.
Then they must have decided application developers have adjusted, and decided to jump to major number 10 for consistency with the official name.
Of course, Windows 11 is still numbered 10, and in fact only the build/fix number are now used to distinguish feature level and fix level.
Back on the topic of XP: I too was not a fan of the default Luna style, but switching to classic mode makes it look like a slightly more colorful (less dull?) Win2K. The icon text background transparency is one major improvement that makes it look more modern.
XP had official security patches up until 2014, unofficially all the way to 2019 (by ‘hacking’ the SKU identifier). It is probably as secure as it can be. Actual security experts (not me) say that it is not really possible to make XP any more secure because of major overhauls of many subsystems that started with Vista and cannot be reasonably backported. Still, the biggest drawback in using XP as a daily driver is lack of support for some modern APIs and root certificates. Legacy Update and Supermium Browser go a great length towards making XP compatible with the modern web. Even “AI mode” works. Some folks claim Supermium is shady, but most of the reviews are positive and trusting.
I recently built myself an XP machine. It probably speaks volumes about me that I simply reused an antec solo case, which I had been using as my everyday PC since about 2010!
I’m really having fun with that machine. As you say, dr_st, It’s sort of amazing actually – I made it to approx 2007 specs, but it feels darn close to being a passable daily driver. Especially with the Supermium browser.
Microsoft’s version numbers are screwy across the board. They jumped from Word for Windows 2 straight to 6 for example. For a while they had two concurrent product lines called “Windows 3.x” which were actually completely different. Windows 95, 98 and Me were actually all just “windows 4”. Windows 2000 and XP were actually both “windows nt5”. There was no Windows NT1 or NT2. They randomly decided to switch back to numbered versions after vista, but the numbers never matched up in any way that made sense. And of course they skipped over 9. I could go on.
Anyway, I remember reviews of XP being mixed as well, but almost in a Stolkholm Syndrome way it stuck around so long that people got used to it and loved it by the end.
I don’t think I ever had strong opinions about the cartoony look of it, but the way operating systems especially by microsoft have been getting blander and more soulless since windows 7, I really appreciate it now.